| Welcome to your weekly board briefing and greetings from the FT’s Future of AI Summit, where I have been hosting and introducing luminaries such as Bill Gates. It’s also the perfect place to celebrate the launch of my latest book Take Note: A Nimble History of Shorthand, out today from Profile Books. It’s the story of a 2,000-year-old workplace technology, with lessons for all of us as we tackle the advance of AI. And speaking of the ebbs and flows of history, this week we lead with the collapse of law firm Weil Gotshal & Manges, alongside top stories on the US midterms, Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg’s efforts to fend off investor lawsuits, and toads. If you want to catch up, why not explore the FT Infosys Board Network hub? You’ll find links to FT.com articles, research that we’ve referenced in recent weeks and our archive of briefings. Do you have comments or suggestions for the newsletter? Send them to Andrew Hill at andrew.hill@ft.com or Kate Hodge at kate.hodge@ft.com Weil: caught out of step with lockstep |
| | |

© Pascal Perich/FT When I used to write about Wall Street in the early 2000s, the idea that law firm Weil Gotshal & Manges might one day simply evaporate seemed unthinkable. Weil became caught in a death spiral after partners fled the firm for better money elsewhere. Law professor John Morley, writing in the FT, compared the implosion to a run on a bank. The outcome is one (admittedly catastrophic) consequence of the way in which lockstep structures, which generally pay by seniority rather than by fees won, have broken down at big law firms. They have been replaced by an eat-what-you-kill approach, which encourages lawyers to look for the biggest payout, even if that means ditching their current firm. As Morley points out, “even if the profits continue to increase in absolute terms, if a firm fails to keep pace with others, it can be thrown out of equilibrium”. Twenty-five years ago, I called Weil regularly with questions about boardroom shenanigans and corporate collapses, partly because Ira Millstein, the great US governance guru, worked there. He served his entire 70-year career at the firm, finally retiring in 2021, three years before his death aged 97. What might he have made of this? He had a long enough run to have seen other firms collapse. But he might well have pointed to a failure of management. Weil’s nominated executive partner decided not to take the job, though it is not clear whether she wanted to avoid the mess she was bound to inherit, or whether her departure contributed to the mess. Possibly both. Either way, a difficult leadership transition was mishandled and previous management has to take the blame for not doing enough to secure its heavy-hitters. In a post-lockstep world, law firm leaders urgently need to find other ways to foster loyalty. But still, the chances any lawyer will approach Millstein’s seven-decade run at one firm are now slim to zero.
 Diamond business De Beers has “shrunk to a whisper of its former glory”, FT journalists wrote this week. The company’s value has sunk to $2.3bn — well below its 2011 valuation of almost $13bn when mining major Anglo American agreed a deal to assume control. Experts say the reasons for the decline include changing consumer habits, and the expansion of cheaper lab-grown stones. But some also point the finger at Anglo. Its time at the helm has included a reduction in advertising for diamonds and launching De Beers’ own lab-grown function, which has since been shelved. 
Six generations, one boardroom: Why strategy oversight depends on generational awareness | PwC “American companies now operate across six living generations,” this guide notes. While it is designed for US businesses, its insights are widely applicable. It explains generational differences and how boards should respond, including asking: “Where could company-wide averages be masking materially different behaviour among the generations most important to our future?” Inside the European C-suite: Profiles in functional leadership | Spencer Stuart This research analysed 2,700 executives, across eight main roles at 489 European public companies. The findings on chief operating officers are interesting. Some 45 per cent of the companies analysed had one, but they seem to be new. The role is “one of the shortest-tenured in the European C-suite” (averaging just 3.6 years) and nearly a quarter (23 per cent) of those analysed were in their first year. The state of third-party risk & integrity | ECI Compliance Week and Diligent This research is based on a small sample of 124 ethics, compliance, and risk professionals (105 complete and 19 partial responses). Fourth-party risk is one area explored. For example, 25 per cent of respondents said they have “little or no visibility” into fourth parties and beyond, while just 6 per cent said they have “broad visibility”.
|